Hi James-
Thanks for reaching out, and thanks for using the Crio WordPress theme.
It looks like this is a bug in Crio, and I’ve filed a bug report for our developers to get this fixed as soon as possible.
Here’s how you can work around it for now. The products are defaulting to showing “in the order in which they were published,” with the newest products showing up first. You can easily change this by using the Quick Edit link in your Products > All Products list, and update your items that you want to show first to have the newest dates and times:
We’ll work to have an update to fix this bug as soon as possible so you don’t have to deal with that inconvenience in the future, and I’ll update you here as soon as we have the release out.