Thanks Brooke,
That’s definitely weird. Try logging into the site using an incognito browser and see if it gives you the same result. I’m thinking there may be some elements lingering around in the database that have yet to have been purged from cache. Also, try clearing any additional cache you might have on the site like browser cache and maybe any server side caching agents.
I hope this helps. Please reach back out to us if you need additional assistance.