Hi Dawn-
Thanks for using W3 Total Cache, I’m sorry to hear that your site speed results are still poor.
Keep in mind that small changes in your testing can also make a huge difference. For example, in this test, I changed the testing location to the US and removed the www.
subdomain, and the score is much better: https://gtmetrix.com/reports/boulderreiki.com/5d2PkHb8/
Enabling a CDN would go a long way to reduce the difference in the geographic location, but since your site seems to be locally-focused it may not be worth the investment.
You mentioned that you already compressed your images, but they’re still taking up over half of your total page size at 1.52MB/2.73MB. It seems like you’re using both Jetpack’s and W3 Total Cache’s lazy loading feature, which is causing lazy loading to fail. I’d recommend only using one lazy loading option to make sure that’s working correctly.